Skip to content

Gaylord Journal · Logistics

Flatten first: the freight math of empty boxes

An assembled gaylord is mostly air, and freight charges for space as much as for weight. The arithmetic behind the biggest lever in moving used packaging.
Published
July 11, 2023
Written by
ReGaylord Boxes
Reading time
8 minutes

Ask about this

Questions on anything in this post reach the people who wrote it. Put it in the message field.

A working business address a partner supplier can reply to

10-digit US or Canadian number

Two-letter code or full name

US ZIP or Canadian postal code

Whole number — units, pallets or truckloads

Free, no-obligation quote request. A partner supplier follows up using the details you give here.

Key takeaways

  • An assembled 48 × 40 × 36 box occupies 40 cubic feet; flattened and banded, the same board takes a small fraction of that space.
  • A trailer of assembled boxes is mostly a trailer of air, which is why flattened loads are so much cheaper per box.
  • Stack height of flattened bundles is limited by crush at the bottom, so ask the supplier for its maximum.
  • A truck that delivers stock and collects empties on the same trip can reduce freight on both legs.

A 53-foot dry van holds a few dozen assembled gaylords floor-loaded. The same trailer holds many hundreds of the same boxes flattened and banded. The exact numbers depend on box size, wall count and how the bundles are stacked, but the order of magnitude is the point: it is the difference between a lane that works and a lane that does not.

Why the ratio is so extreme

A 48 × 40 × 36 box occupies 40 cubic feet of trailer space once it is assembled. Flattened, the same board occupies a small fraction of that. You are shipping identical material either way — the only variable is how much air travels with it.

Freight for something this light is priced on space first and weight second. On a load of empty boxes, most of what you are paying to move is atmosphere.

How the configuration changes the freight picture
ConfigurationBoxes per trailerEffect on freight per box
Assembled, floor-loadedFewestHighest by a wide margin
Assembled, double stackedMore, if the box can bear itLower, but still mostly air
Flattened, banded, stacked moderatelyMany times moreA small fraction of the assembled figure
Flattened, stacked to the supplier's maximumMostLowest for a standalone load
Flattened on a truck already heading that wayMostLowest overall

Read the first and last rows together. The same boxes, the same distance, the same truck type — and a freight cost per box that can differ by an order of magnitude.

Stack height

Flattened boxes are normally banded in lots and stacked. There is a practical limit to how high you can go, because the bottom bundles take the weight of everything above them and eventually crush. The limit varies with board and handling, so ask the supplier what stack height it uses rather than assuming a number.

Backhauls, and what they actually are

A carrier delivering into an area with nothing booked for the return leg has two options: run empty, or take a load that pays something. A load of banded boxes going the direction the truck is already heading can be priced well below a standalone move, because the alternative is running empty.

This is why location and lane can change a delivered price more than order size does. Availability of return capacity is up to the carriers and partner suppliers involved, and it varies by region and season.

The combined move

The most efficient movement in this trade is one truck that arrives with stock and leaves with empties. It can reduce freight on both legs and cut the emissions per box moved.

It needs two things: a load plan agreed in advance, and a dock that can handle an unload and a load in the same window. Many sites can do both. When requesting a quote, say that you have empties to move as well as boxes to buy, and ask whether a partner supplier can combine the two.

Practical checklist

  • Flatten unless there is a specific operational reason not to.
  • Band in consistent lots so counts can be checked without unstacking.
  • Ask the supplier for its maximum stack height for flattened bundles.
  • Ask what return capacity exists on your lane before you assume the freight quote is fixed.
  • Ask whether collection and delivery can share a truck. If the answer is no, ask why.

Questions

Follow-ups on this post.

What if we cannot re-erect flattened boxes on site?
Then assembled delivery is the right answer and the freight is simply the cost. Say so when requesting a quote. For short distances the difference is often small enough not to matter.
Does flattening damage the boxes?
Not if they are banded and stacked sensibly. Repeated folding at the score lines is one genuine cause of wear, so a box that is flattened and re-erected many times will eventually show it, but far more boxes are lost to pallet overhang and moisture than to folding.

Got a question this did not answer?

Send it. We answer every one, and the good ones become the next post.

Get a quote