Skip to content

Yard journal · Specification

Pallet overhang: the two-dollar mistake that costs twenty

A pallet that measures half an inch under specification will quietly destroy every bulk box you put on it. It is the most common avoidable failure we grade, and nobody measures pallets.
Published
April 16, 2024
Written by
Marisol Veracruz-Haddad
Reading time
8 minutes

Ask about this

Questions on anything in this post reach the people who wrote it. Put it in the message field.

A working business address — we reply by email only

US or Canadian number, e.g. (816) 555-0134

Two-letter code or full name, e.g. KS or Kansas

US ZIP (66115 or 66115-1204) or Canadian (M5V 3L9)

Whole number — units, pallets or truckloads

We reply by email — ReGaylord has no telephone line. Your number is only used if a driver needs dock directions. Answered inside one business day.

Key takeaways

  • A pallet measuring 47½ × 39¾ overhangs a 48 × 40 box at every corner and transfers handling load into the bottom edge.
  • Half an inch of overhang per side takes a box from four to six trips down to one or two.
  • Seven or more top deck boards is the practical threshold above 1,500 lb, or use a slip sheet.
  • The cheap pallet saves $3,200 a year and costs nearly $14,000 in containers at 400 boxes a month.

Go and measure five pallets in your building. Actually measure them, with a tape, across the top deck at both ends. If any come in under 47¾ × 39¾ you have an overhang problem you did not know about, and it is currently costing you boxes.

Why half an inch matters so much

A bulk container is designed so that vertical load travels down the side walls and corner columns into the deck below. That transfer only works if the deck is under the wall.

Overhang breaks the path. The bottom edge of the corrugated — structurally the weakest part of the box — starts carrying handling forces instead of passing them into the pallet. Every lift, every set-down and every stack cycle works that edge, and the damage is cumulative and almost invisible until you turn the box over.

Where the undersized pallets come from

  • Repaired pallets where a replacement deck board was cut slightly short.
  • Pallets that have dried and shrunk, particularly older hardwood.
  • Remanufactured pallets built from salvage, where nominal and actual diverge.
  • Pallets that were never 48 × 40 — some regional formats are 47 × 39 or 46 × 40 and look identical on a stack.
  • Metric 1200 × 1000 mm pallets mixed into a GMA pool, which measure 47.24 × 39.37.
Effect of overhang on box life, from our inbound grading
Overhang per sideTypical grade after 3 monthsTrips achievedComment
None2A4 – 6The box performs as designed
⅛ in2A – 3A3 – 5Tolerable; monitor the bottom edge
¼ in3A2 – 4Visible edge wear within weeks
½ in4A1 – 2Bottom edge crush; effectively single trip
¾ in or moreReject1The box is being destroyed by the pallet

Deck boards, the second-order problem

Even with a correctly sized pallet, a five-board top deck under an eighteen-hundred-pound load lets the box base sag between the boards. Over enough cycles that produces score lines in the bottom panel which eventually crack — a different failure from edge crush and just as terminal.

Above roughly fifteen hundred pounds, use seven or more top deck boards, or put a slip sheet between the box and the pallet. The slip sheet costs cents and solves it almost entirely.

Fork entry direction

Notched stringer pallets take a fork cleanly from the ends and awkwardly from the sides. Side entry is where fork tips catch the bottom corner of the corrugated. It produces a very recognisable triangular scuff and we see it constantly.

Two fixes, both cheap: buy block pallets for true four-way entry, or standardise the approach direction in your operation. Either works. Doing neither costs you boxes for as long as you keep doing neither.

The five-minute audit

  1. Measure five random pallets across the top deck, both ends.
  2. Count top deck boards on the pallets carrying your heaviest loads.
  3. Look at whether repairs sit proud of the deck surface. Proud boards point-load the box base.
  4. Turn over five boxes that have been in service a month and look at the bottom edge.
  5. If the edges are worn and the pallets are short, you have found where your packaging budget is going.

Questions

Follow-ups on this post.

How do I know if I have this problem?
Measure five random pallets across the top deck at both ends. Then turn over five boxes that have been in service a month. Short pallets plus worn bottom edges is the diagnosis, and it takes five minutes.
Is underhang a problem too?
Not for the box — a container smaller than the pallet is fully supported. It wastes trailer cube and can allow shifting in transit, but it does not destroy the container the way overhang does.

Marisol Veracruz-Haddad · April 16, 2024 · Specification

Written at the ReGaylord reload yard, 3259 Fiberglass Rd, Kansas City, Kansas. If any of it is wrong, or you have better data, tell us — several of these posts exist in their current form because a customer argued with an earlier one.

Got a question this did not answer?

Send it. We answer every one, and the good ones become the next post.

Get a quote